BrokenHeart

I called the NVC and they said the same thing, interview where you got married, which is HK. (monday call) Today I called the Mesquite Center, the lady was great. She told me file K3 to the Dallas Office and after I receive a reply with my number file a I-129F and send that into the address on the reply. The Visa interview would be in HK where we got married. My question is why another form to file I-129F ? She also stated that my Fiancee App. would fall to the wayside filing the K3.

I did call the National Visa Center and inquired about the goings on of my wifes file. Kelly, at the Center also stated, the file will go to the Consulate where we got married, which is Hong Kong.

Thanks to AGM"S post........................I called the HK Consulate and the wife did also from Shenzhen. We both got the same answer.................Can apply for the K3 through HK with no problem, since we married in HK 2/28/07. I explained the A5 denial thing. They said they would request file and fill out K3 and send there. I also emailed then to make sure and they again said you can apply where you got married. Whats with a light through the tunnel !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A lawyer the wife knows called and the Consulate siad the file was returned to the USA. So, do I have to wait to get a final letter from the State Dept ??? That might take another year !!!!! Do I re-file and submit as wife now??? Do I appeal this ??? ( when I receive notice ) This dog is not going to sit and roll over !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I am going to have to wife call. They have spoke with her before. If the File is still there, what do I say to them keep it in GUZ until I re-file the marriage form ??????? Help me please

I would imagine the case is back in the USA since this happened NOV./06. It would not still be at the GZ office..................would it. I can have the wife call and find out??

This must be some secret book they have to fill the quota of denials. I have looked to and cannot find.

The Consulate is unable to issue you an immigrant visa, according to the section of the INA, section 5A, you do not fulfill the requirements for the petitioned visa. The Consulate has determined, based on your testimony, documents and any other evidence, that you do not have a BONA FIDE RELATIONSHIP with your petitioner. The Consulate will now return your file to Homeland Security.

10/12/06.............BLUE............. wanting plane tickets & hand written docs..................they got the explanation no tickets. PINK..................hand written how we met, and every trip I went to China...................RECEIVED Copy of passport ( not Notorized ) they received White................NOT A BONAFIDE RELATIONSHIP......11/29/06 Done Deal..................................

The wife was denied for NOT A BONAFIED RELATIONSHIP. Now I have to start from scratch again ??? Will the Consulate ask for the file back here in the USA ?? It has all the pertient docs in that file. Does it make a difference if I have the same lawyer prepare all this stuff again ? They did a great job preparing the file with no discrepencies. They have all copies on file with them and know the case. I fulfilled all the docs they wanted hand written. Its the Consulate said better luck if we were married, for what reason I don't know. Need some advice here.