Starberry

I was denied for a funny reason because my fiancee and I were both young! VO told me that he trust our relationship and we can apply again after some time later. I can not understand why thats a reason I can not get the visa! For the white slip reason is bona fide relationship! I always hope thats just a joke. But we have to face the truth. Good luck. True love will overcome all things!

Hi, we met her in Nov of 2007 and i went to guangzhou in January of 2008 and we got engaged, and I applied Feb, 8 2008. She is crying every day, and i have not had a good sleep since i came back last week. The Guangzhou consulate is shamless. Ramin. Why don't you overcome with a CR-1? Seems that is the best way to get on track and prove your relationship. Hi, I don't want to marry and leave my wife back in China and our families don't like the idea of leave her behind in China. If we marry, I have to quite my Job and move to China, then I will live in China until I get the visa for her. I applied for a new K-1 last week again, and we decided If she dose not get second interview now, we will wait another 9 months which they may give us white paper, there are not any rules in Consulate. I will be worry about it at that time, i don't want to be negative from now. I believe in Bahai faith, and can not just marry and leave her behind, If I marry her, i want to be with her. Ramin. I didn't know you could apply another K-1 while one K-1 was just denied. K1 applied again will be approved after the denial one returning back from GUZ to USCIS. But I am not sure apply again that soon. Hope you good luck. I was be denied on JUN for K1, but I am still waiting for USCIS's reviewing now. They told me to wait for 180 days!! OMG!!! But someone said K1 cant appeal, because it has been past due. I am the beneficiary, I can understand your fiancee's mood. Life is always with some difficulty, though I am so much sad on some time. But we have to face the truth. Good Luck!

tsap seui, you and your lady are so strong! I real hope you will be fine. GUZ consulate is unfair sometimes, it waste our time, energy and money. It hurts us so much about our love. But it is realize world. God bless you

Is that mean that K-1 has no any chance to appeal? US government waste our time and waste our money!

Correct, you need to see exactly what was the reason for the NOID, age tends not to be the factor, unless, younger than mariage age in China and/or US citizen's home state. There are a lot of factors that are considered such as ability to support, yet GUZ has been known to give a blue slip and request co-sponsor. Age was not really the factor. The VO can say what he wants, but I am sure that this is what the VO saw... The Petitioner is in school, no job. The Petitioner's Co-Sponsor was not family. So... the VO questions if the family supports the marriage, why do they not Co-Sponsor? In the eyes of the VO, if the application was approved, the Petitioner has no means to support the Beneficiary by the legal requirements, and if the Co-Sponsor is just a friend, it is likely that family does not support, and will not support the Beneficiary. This means the the US government would be liable for such expenses and support. This is likely a partial idea why the VO denied the application. Age, and love is not of importance. The VO even said that he didn't deny their love, he only asked that they return and apply later... when the Petitioner has a job that satisfies the legal requirements, or moves to proceed with a K3/CR1 with followed appropriate support. I am by means no expert, and this is just my 2 cents. It is not my place to say it would have worked, or would have failed. I am perspectively seeing the situation for what factual elements existed. When I look at my own case, I look at the same key items. I am not really nervous, as much as I hope I do not overlook or make a mistake somewhere. I am 23, and my fiance is 21. By the time we get to the interview, she will be 22, and I will be 24. I consider us to be very young, and by no means do I (even with 2 jobs) make what the government requires for me. I too was in college prior to this year and so I never made that limit the government wants. However I do have the support of my family. My father and step-mother with whom I live with currently are helping to Co-Sponsor Wendy. At first they were skeptical of our relationship, but as time has proven and with the journey we have take together thus far has shown to them the light of our love. It was in that stage of out relationship that now my family shares with her and her family. It has brought us even closer together and I could never have seen such a change in people (talking about my very conservative American family), but the world is full of wonderful things! It is the enduring spirit of love and life that will conquer all. As horrible as some things and events in life maybe, it is the individual will and determination of each individual to succeed. And to sweetcherry I say... PROVE THE VO wrong with his comments on the age, and complete the process within the limits of what they are requiring. Anything is possible if you see it so, and if indeed rightly you are justified. I hate to think of the situation, but this is far from a perfect world. Do not give up, just take another turn in the road! You may have tried to to turn right and reached a dead end. Always know that there maybe a detour. Even if the journey is longer, and though you can't turn right, you just may have to turn left three times to get where you need to be. With love and prayers... Dylan. Thanks, Dylan. I read your words for several times. It moved me so much. Thanks so much. I know love is not that easy sometimes. I should be brave to face the difficulties. Bless you.

Hi,Scott, I am Qi's friend. My case is denied on Jun.2008. I sent more than 6 emails to GUZ, there are no any response to me. Then I am so angry. I sent an email to the Department of Citizen in GUZ.(I have told to Qi about this thing). Next day, the department referred my email to the chief of Immigrant Visa Unit. After 2 days later, GUZ IV sent me an email told me about the actual reason of denial. I real hope you can receive your P5 soon. It is so sad for waiting. Bless.

Hello, everyone. I wrote about my interview here several weeks ago. Thanks for your help. Today I received an email form GuangzhouIV. Dear Ms. XXXXX, We have returned your case to the USCIS via NVC for review and possible revocation. A notice is sent to you by mail. You are welcome to contactus again if you do not receive it in two weeks. Immigrant Visa Unit U.S. Consulate General Guangzhou1 Shamian South Street Guangzhou, Guangdong 510133 PRC Fax: 86-20-38844412 My interview was on Jun.3.2008. I was denied because my fiancee and I are too young and with no real income. I want to know what can I do during the case returning? Thanks a lot.

Thank you for everyone here. I have tried to contact Marc Ellis. There is no response now. I know we are real young in age, but I think my fiancee and I are mature in mind and we can overcome it together. Thanks again, I read all your words here carefully. I will catch some advise for me.

Thank you so much for everyone's caring and help here. I feel so warm. My fiancee is free to study in his medical school with amounnt of scholarship. Hence, he need not to pay money for it. He has no loan. And our co-sponsor is not my fiancee's family. She is a so nice Amercian lady. She see my fiancee as her own son and, she wrote a affidavit to vo explain that. On the I-134, she wrote she would try her best to help us because she loves her "son", and want he get a happiness marriage. My fiancee's parents' tax return is not high enough because, they have house loan. So they just made I-186A, but vo did not see it. Thank you again.

I am so sad that I was denied by Guangzhou consular in the interview. During the interview, the visa officer said my fiancee and I was too young to make serious decisions about marriage. In fact, I am 20 and my fiancee is 21 years old. And my fiancee is a full time student now in a seven year medical school now. In addition, on the denial letter the visa officer mentioned not a single word of this statement of my fiancee and I being too young to make marriage decisions. Instead, he stated on the letter that we fail to provide proof of our relationship. Yet, during the interview, when he was offered numerous proves of our relationship, he refused to see them, and specifically stated in front of me that he fully believed in the credibility of our relationship. After some days, my fiancee wrote a email to GuangzhouIV asking about our case. The response was that we are 20 and 21 without real income. In fact, we have co-sponsor. But they did not mention one word about it. Follow the consulate's letter, is that means full time students can not marry because they have no real income? Full time students have no right to petition their fiancee to come to the United Stated? And full time students are too young to make serious decisions about marriage? My fiancee is a seven-year medcial school student and he has 3 years left to finish all his studies. We do not want to wait that long to be with each. Being mere students, we feel very powerless in this situation. the processing interview: we talked in chinese me: hello vo:hello me:this is my passport vo:how old are you me:21, I have my fiancee's passport, do you want to see? vo:no me:I have a letter my fiancee wrote to you. vo:I dont need, pick it up. how did u know each? me:My high school classmate is our introducer. vo:when did u meet the first time? me:Apr.X.2007. I have photos, do you want to see? vo:no. how many times have you met? me: twice. the first isXXX, the second is XXXX vo: When did your fiancee go to US? me:Dec.XX.1996, his dad applied him. I have his parents' photos, do you want to see? vo:no. me:I have my fiancee's school scores letter, do you want to see? vo:yes, I want to see. do you have the tax return? me:yes, I have our fiancial sponsor's photos with my fiancee, do you want to see? vo: yes then, vo called a chinese to come, told english to her. The chinese stuff told me, vo think we were too young and we can apply again after some time. he can not give me the visa. I feel so sad, then I said english to vo. me:why, I have many photos about our engagement party,do you want to see? vo:no me: we are true love, I love my fiancee so much. vo:yes, I trust your relationship. you see, you are both young, and your fiancee's income is low. me: he is a full time student, we have fiancial sponsor. vo: yes, I trust your relationship. you can apply again after some time. I talked with vo for a long time, and want to change the white paper. but failed. Then I have to go. On the white paper is said our relationship is not true. Now my fiancee will appeal in US, and apply CR after our marriage. But I still worry about my fiancee's income. Next year, he will still have no income. Well, we will still ask our lawyer about it. I also want you here can help me. Thanks a lot